Must a doctoral hood have a cape?

The Academic Costume Code of the American Council on Education, on the subject of hoods, says “the hood for the doctor’s degree only shall have panels at the sides”.  Does this mean (i) “Only a hood for a doctoral degree shall have panels at the side” (in which case the panels are optional)? Or does it mean: (ii) “In the case of the doctoral degree only, there shall be panels at the side” (in which case the side panels are required)?

 The "panels at the side" constitute the CAPE for a "full" (as opposed to a "simple" hood) on Grove's classification.  A hood without a cape will be lighter and so less prone to the slipping/strangling common with academic hoods.  But will it be authentically doctoral?

 Evidence for (ii)?
Gardner Cottrell Leonard, The Cap and Gown in America, (Albany, 1896) on pages 12 and 13 illustrates Bachelor’s Master’s and Doctoral Hoods, and the latter have capes/side panels.  Here is the illustration from p. 13

Evidence for (i)?
In all of the rented regalia I have worn over the years—rented by my university, so presumably up to their standards— the hoods are cape-less/ panel-less.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How I got started

Image
After going through enough commencement and graduation ceremonies in a rented gown, hood, and cap & hating the cheesy quality (like wearing a glorified dry cleaner bag), I started to think that I’d like to have my own, in decent quality fabric. After finding it costs circa $1000 for a decent set, I decided to investigate what it would take to make a set of my own (as a diversion as well a cost-saving/quality enhancing exercise). At first I thought about the gown, and learned a lot from a blogger who constructed her own PhD robe (not cap and hood) in 2008.   Starting with a Butterick pattern 5626 (church/choir robe) and altering it (single pleat in front instead of gathers, adding velvet collar and trim around front opening, and adjusting sleeves to puff around a shorter lining, cartridge pleating instead of gathering) as well as adding chevrons and piping per her alma mater’s design, she ended up with a very impressive reproduction of her school’s official robes, in a
Read more

Hood

Image
At first I thought I’d just purchase the hood, since I found it hard to identify the principles of construction for this dangling-strangling-slipping contraption.   But I’ve done some research and think this is a doable project.   The basic idea is that the academic hood is a stylized version of a medieval robin-hood type hood .      Here’s a sketch of the  pattern  for the ordinary hood.  The main parts are the COWL (opening around face), CAPE/GORGET (the part that sits around the neck) and LIRIPIPE (the point at the peak, back of head). In the stylized academic hood, the cowl and cape are extremely elongated, with all kinds of variation on the shape and length of the liripipe.   Via Wikipedia, I found an extremely useful chart of basic shapes of different doctoral hoods, including the pattern for each!   I determined, from looking at photos online, that the pattern than best fits my alma mater’s doctoral hood is of the Aberdeen style, and the closest matches
Read more

Robe

Image
Detail of illustration from   Gardner Cottrell Leonard, The Cap and Gown in America , (Albany, 1896), p. 15.    Since the academic gown is a version of a medieval robe, I considered starting with a costume for a medieval dress (less unisex, but who cares?). Perhaps a version of McCalls 4492 with great bell sleeves (minus the over-bodice, and without the upper arm puffing, maybe with enlarged arm holes, and cartridge pleating attaching the sleeve to bodice). Or perhaps McCalls5155 (minus the sash, and swapping in the bell sleeves from McCalls 4492).   One drawback: the pattern is for a dress not an overgarment, and so unless I made it several sizes larger, it would not be something to wear over regular clothes (as per usual academic gown).   This isn’t necessarily a problem, since it is often very hot here in mid May for commencement.   Still, in some years it is cool enough for the extra layer.   Another drawback:   there is no feature of the gown suitable for attaching and anch
Read more